Competition winner: Breaking the Code of Silence

By continuing to use our site you consent to the use of cookies as described in our privacy policy unless you have disabled them.
You can change your cookie settings at any time but parts of our site will not function correctly without them.
This case series won the Outstanding Case Writer Competition at The Case Centre Awards and Competitions 2018.

Who – the protagonist

Nina (name changed), Senior Correspondent at Tehelka, an Indian weekly news magazine.

What?

Veteran journalist Tarun Tejpal founded Tehelka, breaking new ground in investigative journalism using sting operations. Tejpal was considered a crusader for women’s rights and a champion of the underprivileged.

Woman writing on a pad of paper

Nina was a young, promising journalist in her twenties, working her way up from an intern. Nina had known Tejpal from her childhood, as the latter worked closely with her father, who was also a senior journalist.

Nina wrote many articles on feminist topics, such as the relationship between society, law and rape and held some clout within the media circuits.

Why?

According to Nina, her world turned upside down when Tejpal, someone she trusted and looked up to, sexually assaulted her in an elevator – on two separate occasions.

The incidents occurred while Nina was chaperoning well-known Hollywood actor Robert De Niro, and his daughter Drenon, at THiNK Fest, an annual event hosted by Tehelka, attended by popular panellists and celebrities.

When?

It was November 2013 when Nina was allegedly sexually assaulted.

Where?

THiNK Fest was held at the Grand Hyatt Hotel in the Indian state of Goa, situated on the west coast.

Key quote

“As a reporter for Tehelka who writes on violence against women, I suddenly find myself in the horrific situation of discovering what it is like to be on the receiving end of this violence from a powerful man I once deeply admired and respected.”
Nina, Senior Correspondent at Tehelka

What next?

As a journalist who in all her writing had always urged women to speak out and break the silence that surrounded sexual crime Nina found herself at a crossroads.

Does she stay true to herself and report the incident to her senior colleague and police, or would remaining silent protect her safety, job and Tehelka?

AUTHOR PERSPECTIVE 

Raising awareness

They continued: “The objective of writing this case was not to sit in judgement of the alleged perpetrator of the sexual violence, or to speculate on what really happened; the law will take its course in this regard.

Woman at a desk looking uncomfortable as a male colleague rests his hands on her shoulders

“However, the incident provided us with the tremendous opportunity to bring to light the often unspoken world of sexual harassment in the workplace. With issues like sexual harassment dominating the global conversation, and reports weighing in on the ethical and social issues of the day, we felt this case would help bring these critical issues to the classroom, and also help find solutions to this problem. The case provides an opportunity to discuss what to do and, more specifically, what to say when faced with sexual harassment.

“It is our belief that this case allows us to raise awareness among business students, as well as corporate managers, about the perils of unethical behaviour and poor corporate governance in the workplace. Broadly, it prepares students and trainees to speak up when confronted with ethical dilemmas.

“The case resonated very well with a diverse set of educators who said that there was a need felt for such a case for a long time.”

Students engage with the subject

Syeda, Debapratim and Vijaya added: “This case has been taught in both undergraduate and MBA courses in Strategic Management in the US and was received well in all of them. Students responded to the questions posed with enthusiasm and candour, with one commenting:

“At first, I did not see how it is relevant to a business strategy course, but after the case was discussed, I now see how it applies to ethics, leadership, corporate strategy and governance.”

THE CASE 

The case

Who – the protagonist

Nina (name changed), Senior Correspondent at Tehelka, an Indian weekly news magazine.

What?

Veteran journalist Tarun Tejpal founded Tehelka, breaking new ground in investigative journalism using sting operations. Tejpal was considered a crusader for women’s rights and a champion of the underprivileged.

Woman writing on a pad of paper

Nina was a young, promising journalist in her twenties, working her way up from an intern. Nina had known Tejpal from her childhood, as the latter worked closely with her father, who was also a senior journalist.

Nina wrote many articles on feminist topics, such as the relationship between society, law and rape and held some clout within the media circuits.

Why?

According to Nina, her world turned upside down when Tejpal, someone she trusted and looked up to, sexually assaulted her in an elevator – on two separate occasions.

The incidents occurred while Nina was chaperoning well-known Hollywood actor Robert De Niro, and his daughter Drenon, at THiNK Fest, an annual event hosted by Tehelka, attended by popular panellists and celebrities.

When?

It was November 2013 when Nina was allegedly sexually assaulted.

Where?

THiNK Fest was held at the Grand Hyatt Hotel in the Indian state of Goa, situated on the west coast.

Key quote

“As a reporter for Tehelka who writes on violence against women, I suddenly find myself in the horrific situation of discovering what it is like to be on the receiving end of this violence from a powerful man I once deeply admired and respected.”
Nina, Senior Correspondent at Tehelka

What next?

As a journalist who in all her writing had always urged women to speak out and break the silence that surrounded sexual crime Nina found herself at a crossroads.

Does she stay true to herself and report the incident to her senior colleague and police, or would remaining silent protect her safety, job and Tehelka?

AUTHOR PERSPECTIVE 

Author perspective

Raising awareness

They continued: “The objective of writing this case was not to sit in judgement of the alleged perpetrator of the sexual violence, or to speculate on what really happened; the law will take its course in this regard.

Woman at a desk looking uncomfortable as a male colleague rests his hands on her shoulders

“However, the incident provided us with the tremendous opportunity to bring to light the often unspoken world of sexual harassment in the workplace. With issues like sexual harassment dominating the global conversation, and reports weighing in on the ethical and social issues of the day, we felt this case would help bring these critical issues to the classroom, and also help find solutions to this problem. The case provides an opportunity to discuss what to do and, more specifically, what to say when faced with sexual harassment.

“It is our belief that this case allows us to raise awareness among business students, as well as corporate managers, about the perils of unethical behaviour and poor corporate governance in the workplace. Broadly, it prepares students and trainees to speak up when confronted with ethical dilemmas.

“The case resonated very well with a diverse set of educators who said that there was a need felt for such a case for a long time.”

Students engage with the subject

Syeda, Debapratim and Vijaya added: “This case has been taught in both undergraduate and MBA courses in Strategic Management in the US and was received well in all of them. Students responded to the questions posed with enthusiasm and candour, with one commenting:

“At first, I did not see how it is relevant to a business strategy course, but after the case was discussed, I now see how it applies to ethics, leadership, corporate strategy and governance.”

THE CASE 

Celebrating the win

Vi was presented with her trophy, by our Director, Richard McCracken, at AOM 2018 in Chicago on 11 August 2018.

Vijaya Narapareddy and Richard McCracken

Debapratim and Syeda were presented with their awards by our Director, Richard McCracken, in Hyderabad on 16 November 2018.

Debapratim Purkayastha, Richard McCracken, Syeda Maseeha Qumer and Dr J. Mahender Reddy
Debapratim Purkayastha, Richard McCracken, Syeda Maseeha Qumer and Dr J. Mahender Reddy
Read the case

Educators can login to view a free educator preview copy of this case and its teaching note.

CASE - Reference no. 718-0006-1
TEACHING NOTE - Reference no. 718-0006-8
CASE - Reference no. 717-0071-1B
Get our newsletter

Stay in touch with all the latest case news and views in our free newsletter, Connect.

Read it online or sign up to have it delivered direct to your inbox!

Picture representing 'Get our newsletter'
Picture representing 'Get our newsletter'
Get our newsletter

Stay in touch with all the latest case news and views in our free newsletter, Connect.

Read it online or sign up to have it delivered direct to your inbox!

Discover more